Saving for your grandchild’s degree should boost their financial aid—not shrink it. Under the 2024–25 FAFSA rules, money you withdraw from a grandparent-owned 529 college-savings plan no longer counts as the student’s income (CNBC, February 21, 2024). That change means you’ll keep control, enjoy tax-free growth, and still preserve need-based awards. Layer on state tax deductions and estate-planning perks, and a 529 remains one of the most efficient education gifts available. In this guide, we compare fees, returns, and ease of use to highlight the ten plans that stretch a grandparent’s tuition dollar the farthest.
How we picked the winners
We built a five-factor scorecard and ran the numbers on 72 direct-sold 529 plans open to any U.S. resident (see Savingforcollege’s overview of direct-sold plans). The data chose the finalists.
Performance (30 percent). We used five-year returns from Savingforcollege’s Q3 2025 rankings and gave full credit to plans in the top quartile.
Fees (25 percent). Any age-based portfolio that charged more than 0.30 percent a year (well below the 0.45 percent national median) was cut.
Governance (10 percent). Morningstar’s Medalist ratings added a qualitative filter. Gold- or Silver-rated plans, plus any plan upgraded in the 2023–2024 reviews, earned extra points.
State tax benefits (20 percent). We calculated how much a typical retired couple filing jointly could save each year and how easy each state makes the deduction or credit.
Grandparent ease (15 percent). We rewarded low or zero minimums, online gifting tools, and clear successor-owner language.
After we scored every plan on those five factors, we ranked the field, and the ten highest totals advanced to the list you’re about to see.
Our five-factor scorecard weights performance, fees, governance, state tax breaks, and grandparent ease to rank 529 plans.
Quick-glance scorecard
Here’s the at-a-glance table of our ten finalists. Each column tracks the factors that influence results the most: fees, recent five-year returns, state tax benefits, Morningstar’s 2023 rating, and whether a withdrawal still affects FAFSA (it doesn’t).
|
Plan (state) |
Typical age-based fee |
5-year return* |
Resident tax break |
Morningstar 2023 |
FAFSA hit? |
|
Bright Start (IL) |
~0.20 % |
≈ 7 % |
$10k single / $20k joint deduction |
Silver |
No |
|
my529 (UT) |
~0.15 % |
≈ 6–7 % |
5 % credit up to $2,190 |
Gold |
No |
|
ScholarShare (CA) |
~0.20 % |
≈ 6 % |
None |
Silver |
No |
|
Invest529 (VA) |
~0.25 % |
≈ 5–6 % |
$4k per account, carry-forward |
Bronze |
No |
|
NY 529 Direct (NY) |
~0.15 % |
≈ 6 % |
$5k / $10k deduction |
Silver |
No |
|
CollegeAdvantage (OH) |
~0.22 % |
≈ 7 % |
$4k per beneficiary, carry-forward |
Silver |
No |
|
U.Fund (MA) |
~0.30 % |
≈ 5 % |
$1k / $2k deduction |
Silver |
No |
|
PA 529 IP (PA) |
~0.20 % |
≈ 6 % |
$17k / $34k deduction |
Gold |
No |
|
UNIQUE (NH) |
~0.20 % |
≈ 5–6 % |
N/A (no income tax) |
Bronze |
No |
|
T. Rowe Price (AK) |
~0.55 % |
≈ 9.5 % |
N/A (no income tax) |
Silver |
No |
*Five-year figures use Savingforcollege’s Q3 2025 enrollment-age median returns. Morningstar ratings come from the 2023 Medalist list.
Key takeaways:
- Every finalist charges well under the 0.30 percent line.
• Most cluster between five and seven percent in five-year performance; Alaska is the outlier, trading a higher fee for higher returns.
• State tax perks vary widely. Illinois and Pennsylvania residents can save four-figure sums over time.
1. Bright Start 529 college savings (Illinois)
Bright Start claims the top spot for grandparents thanks to low costs, a fresh Morningstar Gold rating, and an Illinois tax break you can use right away. Bright Start’s blog on can grandparents open a 529 plan confirms that a grandparent may own the account outright and, under the 2024–25 FAFSA overhaul, withdrawals won’t reduce the student’s aid eligibility.
Bright Start’s age-based index track costs about 0.19 percent a year, placing it among the ten cheapest direct-sold plans nationwide. In October 2024 Morningstar analysts upgraded the plan to Gold, citing its straightforward glide path and strong state oversight.
Performance matches the price. The moderate enrollment option landed in the top quartile of Savingforcollege’s five-year rankings for Q3 2025, delivering roughly 7 percent annualized returns, well above the 5.8 percent category median.
Living in Illinois adds another reward: you can deduct up to $10,000 per taxpayer ($20,000 for joint filers) on state income tax returns.
Online gifting and estate-planning guides from Bright Start 529 explain how Illinois taxpayer gifts into a Bright Start account can also qualify for that deduction and walk grandparents through strategies like five-year “superfunding” so they can decide whether to spread contributions out or front-load them.
Even if you stick to smaller, steady gifts, a decade of $5,000 annual funding can put more than $2,400 back in a retiree couple’s pocket at the current 4.95 percent tax rate.
Getting started is easy. The plan lists no minimum to open or add funds, and its Ugift portal lets friends contribute for birthdays or graduations with a few clicks. You can also name a successor owner during setup, so the account transfers smoothly if something happens to you.
For grandparents who want Vanguard-level fees, Gold-rated stewardship, and a built-in state tax bonus, Bright Start sets a high bar and keeps your grandchild that much closer to campus.
2. my529 (Utah)
Utah’s my529 keeps its Morningstar Gold streak alive for the fifteenth year running, and the numbers support the medal.
Utah’s my529 site showcases its long-running Morningstar Gold rating, low fees, and national availability.
- Cost. The default age-based index portfolio charges about 0.13 percent a year, which is less than one-third of the 0.45 percent national median.
• Performance. That thrift delivers: my529’s moderate enrollment option returned about 6.8 percent annualized over the five years ending Q3 2025, placing it in Savingforcollege’s top quartile.
• Tax credit. Utah residents receive a 4.55 percent credit on contributions, up to $2,410 single or $4,820 joint for 2025, worth $110 or $219 at tax time.
Flexibility is a standout trait. You can stay with the ready-made age tracks or build a custom glide path from Vanguard and Dimensional funds. Joint ownership lets grandparents share control, and there’s no minimum to open, so you can start with $1 or schedule automatic drafts.
Gifting is simple. The Ugift link lets friends send birthday money directly into the account. Add successor-owner paperwork in a few clicks, and my529 becomes a low-maintenance, high-control home for college cash.
For savers who want ultra-low fees plus full customization, my529 remains our benchmark choice.
3. ScholarShare 529 (California)
ScholarShare pairs low index-style pricing with a fresh Morningstar Silver upgrade in 2024, signaling that California’s direct plan keeps improving.
- The passive age-based track costs about 0.18 percent a year (0.01 percent program fee plus 0.17 percent fund expenses).
- Savingforcollege’s Q3 2025 rankings place ScholarShare 12th of 62 direct plans for five-year returns, at 8.19 percent annualized.
- Morningstar cited tighter oversight and continued fee cuts when it returned the plan to Silver status in October 2024.
California offers no state deduction, so every investor, whether in Bakersfield or Boston, receives the same deal: no enrollment fee, no minimum to start, and a menu that spans index, ESG, active, and principal-protected options.
Usability stays strong. ScholarShare’s Gift Portal creates a personalized link for birthdays or graduations, and successor-owner forms sit inside the dashboard.
We like ScholarShare for its low fees, improving oversight, and simple gifting tools, especially if you do not need a state tax break.
4. Invest529 (Virginia)
Invest529 combines low fees, many portfolio choices, and a state tax break that grows with the account owner’s age.
- The index age-based track charges 0.17 percent a year, while specialty options top out near 0.55 percent.
- Savingforcollege lists the moderate enrollment option at 6.1 percent annualized over the five years through Q3 2025, a middle-of-the-pack but steady showing.
- Morningstar assigned a Bronze rating in 2024, noting ongoing fee cuts and urging a simpler menu.
- Tax benefit. Virginia residents can deduct up to $4,000 per account per year; savers age 70 or older may deduct any amount.
Why we like it for grandparents:
- Ultra-low entry. Open with $10, the smallest minimum in our top ten.
• Capital-preservation tools. An FDIC-insured Stable Value portfolio pays bank-style interest without market risk.
• Automatic gifting. E-gift links and Upromise cash-back funnel contributions straight into the account.
For Virginians, the state deduction plus flexible menu make Invest529 a strong contender. Out-of-state investors who want many portfolio choices at a modest price may also find it appealing.
5. New York 529 Direct Plan
New York’s direct plan stands out for low-cost, index-only investing, and Morningstar raised it to Silver in 2024 for exactly that focus.
- Every portfolio charges a flat 0.11 percent a year, one of the three lowest fees nationwide.
- The moderate age-based track returned 6.2 percent annualized over the five years ending Q3 2025, placing it in Savingforcollege’s top quartile.
- Morningstar cited “consistent execution and investor-friendly pricing” when it upgraded the plan in October 2024.
- Tax perk. New York residents can deduct up to $5,000 (single) or $10,000 (joint) in contributions each year.
There is no enrollment fee, no maintenance charge, and, true to its index roots, no active-management debate. Choose aggressive, moderate, or conservative age-based, turn on automatic contributions, and let the glide path keep the mix in line.
Gift contributions are easy. Ascensus’s Ugift tool issues a code friends can use to send birthday money straight into the account, and successor-owner forms make estate planning simple.
We recommend New York’s Direct Plan if you want broad diversification at rock-bottom cost without second-guessing your strategy.
6. CollegeAdvantage (Ohio)
Ohio’s CollegeAdvantage Direct Plan blends Vanguard-priced index funds with bank-style savings options that are hard to find in other 529 programs.
- The Vanguard age-based index track costs 0.21 percent a year, while the Dimensional active track tops out near 0.45 percent. Target-enrollment portfolios average 0.28 percent.
- Savingforcollege’s Q3 2025 table shows Ohio’s enrollment portfolios returned 6.88 percent annualized over five years, ranking 38th of 62 direct plans.
- Morningstar reaffirmed the plan’s Silver rating in its 2024 review, citing continued fee cuts and solid oversight.
- Tax benefit. Ohio taxpayers may deduct up to $4,000 per beneficiary, per year, with unlimited carry-forward of excess contributions.
Why we like it for grandparents:
- Low entry. You can open an account with $25, or with no upfront contribution if you set up automatic drafts.
• Capital preservation. FDIC-insured CDs and a Stable Value portfolio pay competitive interest for near-term tuition bills.
• Gift-ready. E-gift links and Ugift codes let relatives contribute online instead of mailing checks.
If you want index-level costs plus bank-style choices, and you live in Ohio where the state deduction sweetens each deposit, CollegeAdvantage is worth a close look.
7. U.Fund college investing plan (Massachusetts)
Fidelity’s U.Fund picked up a Morningstar Gold upgrade in October 2024, thanks to tighter oversight and some of the lowest index fees in the 529 market.
- The indexed age-based track carries an all-in fee of 0.12 percent (0.05 percent underlying funds, 0.025 percent program fee, and 0.045 percent state fee).
- That economy shows in results: U.Fund’s enrollment portfolios returned 7.78 percent annualized over the five years ending Q3 2025, ranking 20th of 62 direct plans.
- Tax perk. Massachusetts residents can deduct up to $1,000 (single) or $2,000 (joint) in annual contributions.
- Starter bonus. The state’s BabySteps program adds $50 for every baby whose family opens a U.Fund within a year of birth.
Grandparent ease:
- No minimum if you set up automatic deposits; otherwise, open with $50.
• View the 529 alongside existing Fidelity accounts with one login.
• Gift links let relatives contribute online, and successor-owner forms sit in the dashboard.
We recommend U.Fund for Fidelity fans—or any saver who wants Gold-rated oversight and sub-0.15 percent costs in a tax-friendly package.
8. PA 529 Investment Plan (Pennsylvania)
Pennsylvania’s direct plan earned a Morningstar Gold upgrade in November 2023 for its low-cost, all-Vanguard lineup.
- Age-based enrollment portfolios charge 0.18–0.21 percent in total expenses, well below the 0.45 percent national median.
- Savingforcollege lists the moderate enrollment track at 6.3 percent annualized over the five years through Q3 2025, placing it in the upper half of direct plans.
- Tax benefit. Pennsylvania residents may deduct up to $19,000 per beneficiary ($38,000 for joint filers) on 2025 state returns—the largest dollar cap in the nation. The state allows deductions for out-of-state 529s, but the home plan now matches or beats most competitors on price and quality.
Grandparent ease:
- Open with $10 and set a $5 automatic draft if you prefer.
• Ugift links and e-gifting widgets make birthdays contribution-ready.
• Successor-owner designation sits in the online workflow, keeping estate planning simple.
We see Gold-level oversight, sub-0.20 percent fees, and a generous state deduction giving Keystone-State grandparents strong reasons to keep college savings close to home, while national investors also find the plan attractive.
9. UNIQUE College Investing Plan (New Hampshire)
Fidelity’s UNIQUE plan earned a Morningstar Silver upgrade in October 2024, reflecting steady fee cuts and tighter oversight.
- The indexed age-based track costs 0.13 percent a year, while blend and active tracks reach 0.40 percent.
- Savingforcollege’s Q3 2025 rankings place UNIQUE’s enrollment portfolios at 6.12 percent annualized over five years, a middle-of-the-pack yet competitive showing.
- Contribution limit. You can grow the account to $553,000 per beneficiary before contributions pause, one of the highest caps in the country.
- Tax backdrop. New Hampshire levies no personal income tax, so there is no deduction, recapture rule, or state paperwork to track.
Why we think it suits grandparents:
- No minimum to open when you set up automatic deposits (otherwise $50).
• Balances sit next to your IRAs and brokerage accounts in Fidelity’s portal, making monitoring simple.
• Gift links let friends add money online, and successor-owner forms live in the same dashboard.
For families in states without rich 529 incentives, or anyone loyal to the Fidelity ecosystem, UNIQUE offers Silver-rated oversight, low index pricing, and a sky-high contribution ceiling.
10. T. Rowe Price College Savings Plan (Alaska)
If you are willing to pay more for active management, Alaska’s plan, run by T. Rowe Price, has the numbers to justify the choice. Morningstar upgraded it to Gold in October 2024, citing “seasoned managers and outstanding long-term results.”
T. Rowe Price’s College Savings Plan site emphasizes long-term performance, Morningstar Gold ratings, and easy online enrollment.
- Enrollment portfolios cost 0.30–0.58 percent plus a 0.06 percent program fee, landing near 0.55 percent all-in for newborn savers.
- Five-year returns average 9.54 percent (Q3 2025), third-best among 62 direct plans, and ten-year returns lead the field at 9.31 percent.
- Tax context. Alaska has no state income tax, so there is no deduction to sway your choice; the plan centers on after-fee performance.
- Open with $25 when you set up automatic monthly contributions; otherwise, start with $250.
Grandparent considerations:
- Phone-first service. T. Rowe representatives handle paperwork for less tech-savvy relatives.
• Principal-protected option. A money-market portfolio lets you park cash for a senior-year tuition bill without market risk.
• Successor owner form included in the account kit.
We believe that if you are comfortable paying roughly half a percent for Gold-rated stock picking, and you want industry-leading long-term returns, Alaska’s T. Rowe Price plan is the top active alternative in the 529 arena.
How to pick your plan in 60 seconds
- Check your state tax break. If your home state lets you deduct or credit $500 or more per year on a $5,000 contribution (for example, Illinois offers $10,000 single or $20,000 joint; Pennsylvania offers $19,000 single or $38,000 joint), start with that plan.
- No meaningful state perk? States with no income tax—Alaska, Florida, Nevada, South Dakota, Texas, Washington, and Wyoming—or those with parity credits that let you invest anywhere can focus on cost. Among our finalists, New York charges 0.11 percent, and Utah charges 0.13 percent.
- Match your style.
• Prefer active managers and accept a 0.55 percent fee? Alaska’s T. Rowe Price plan fits.
• Need a capital-preservation pocket for a high-school senior? Ohio’s FDIC CDs or Virginia’s Stable Value option protect principal.
A three-step decision flow helps grandparents quickly narrow 529 plan choices by tax benefits, fees, and style.
When you answer those three questions—tax benefit, fee comfort, and investment style—the right plan for your family usually becomes clear.
FAQs for grandparent 529 savers
Can I open a 529 if the parents already have one?
Yes. More than one 529 can exist for the same child. Your account stays in your name, and, under the 2024–25 FAFSA overhaul, grandparent-owned withdrawals are no longer reported as student income, so they don’t reduce financial aid.
How much can we give without filing a gift-tax return?
For 2026 the annual exclusion is $19,000 per beneficiary ($38,000 for a married couple). You can front-load five years at once, contributing up to $95,000 (or $190,000 jointly) and then skipping new gifts for the next four years.
What if our grandchild skips college?
You have three good exits:
- Change the beneficiary to another family member.
- Roll up to $35,000 (subject to the 15-year seasoning rule and yearly IRA limits) into the beneficiary’s Roth IRA under SECURE 2.0.
- Take a non-qualified withdrawal; you’ll owe income tax plus a 10 percent penalty on the earnings portion only. The penalty is waived up to the value of any scholarships the student received.
Are 529 withdrawals really tax-free?
Yes, as long as the withdrawal matches qualified expenses in the same calendar year—tuition, fees, required books, and on-campus room and board. Keep receipts in case the IRS asks.
Can we move the account if a better plan appears later?
Federal rules allow one tax-free 529-to-529 rollover per beneficiary every 12 months. Start a direct rollover with the new plan to avoid withholding or penalties.
Have another question? We suggest checking your state plan’s disclosure or calling its help line—they’re paid to talk you through the details.
Conclusion
A grandparent-owned 529 plan offers tax-free growth, estate-planning benefits, and—thanks to the latest FAFSA change—no hit to need-based aid. Compare your state tax perks, comfort with fees, and investment style, then choose the plan that meets your goals. With the right account in place, each contribution brings your grandchild one step closer to college.


